One new Coles, one IGA 2km away: the Kalgoorlie supermarket fight that will set the rules for every big chain now waits on a tribunal
Coles has finished arguing that the competition watchdog was wrong to stop it opening a second supermarket and liquor store in Kalgoorlie-Boulder, warning the decision will have a "chilling effect" on investment. The ACCC says the new store could push the city's closest independent rival out of business and leave shoppers with less choice. The Australian Competition Tribunal has reserved its decision and must rule within 90 days.
Three things to know
- It is the first time the ACCC has used Australia's new merger powers to block a deal outright, and the tribunal's ruling will guide how every big retailer and shopping centre developer plans new sites.
- The deal is not a takeover: it is Coles leasing land for a new store on the edge of Kalgoorlie-Boulder, about 2km from O'Connor Fresh IGA, which says it could close.
- The decision is due within 90 days of the hearing ending on Thursday 19 November, which points to a ruling by about mid-February 2027.
A single supermarket on a patch of bushland in Kalgoorlie-Boulder has become the biggest test yet of Australia’s new merger laws, and the Goldfields city of about 30,000 people now has to wait up to three months to learn whether it gets it.
Eight days of hearings before the Australian Competition Tribunal in Melbourne ended on Thursday. The three-member panel, led by Federal Court Justice Michael O’Bryan, has reserved its decision.
What did the ACCC block, and why?
In the middle of this year the ACCC used new powers to stop Coles leasing land in Somerville, on the city’s outskirts, to build a new supermarket and liquor store. Developer M/Group planned to lease the site to Coles as part of its Amara Estate near the airport. Coles already runs a store in the city centre.
The watchdog’s concern was not that Coles would get too big, but that its arrival could force out a smaller, different kind of competitor. ACCC barrister Declan Roche SC told the tribunal Kalgoorlie-Boulder was a “concentrated market” and that the new store would be a “substantial lessening of competition”.
He said O’Connor Fresh IGA, about 2km from the proposed site, mattered because its trading hours are not regulated the way Coles’s are, which suits the city’s many shift workers. He said Coles’s own business case showed part of the new store’s trade would come from the IGA. The Kalgoorlie-Boulder Chamber of Commerce and Industry backed the ACCC.
Lawyers for O’Connor Fresh IGA, which joined the case, argued there was a real commercial possibility it would go out of business.
What does Coles say?
Coles lodged its appeal in July. Its barrister, John Sheahan KC, said the uncertainty created by the decision would “plausibly and likely have a chilling effect on proposed investments” across the country.
He said all of Kalgoorlie’s shoppers would benefit from a new store, and that Woolworths was unlikely to take the opening “lying down”, pointing to more investment by rivals. He compared Kalgoorlie-Boulder with 10 regional centres of similar size, all of which have more supermarkets. The city has six now.
Justice O’Bryan described the case as a “difficult dilemma”: weighing the benefits of a new store against the possible loss of a competitor down the track.
Why does this matter beyond the Goldfields?
Australia’s merger rules changed this year so that significant deals, including some property and lease acquisitions by big retailers, must be cleared by the ACCC before they go ahead. Kalgoorlie is the first deal the watchdog has opposed under that system, so the tribunal’s ruling will shape how far the ACCC can go in protecting smaller players.
For shoppers in regional towns, the question is a sharp one: is a town better served by one more big-chain supermarket now, or by keeping the independent that gives them later hours and a different choice? Coles has 860 supermarkets nationally.
The market has already shifted once. Tony Galati’s Spudshed opened in the city last year and, according to the IGA’s counsel, prompted a competitive response from the national chains.
How we got here
The key moments that brought this story into focus. Open any moment for detail.
1986Coles arrives
Coles begins a 35-year run of two stores in Kalgoorlie-Boulder, which ends in 2021.
2025Spudshed opens
Tony Galati's Spudshed opens in the city.
Mid-2026ACCC blocks the store
The watchdog opposes Coles's lease of the Somerville site, its first opposition under the new merger laws.
July 2026Coles appeals
Coles applies to the Australian Competition Tribunal for a review.
19 November 2026Hearings end
Eight days of hearings in Melbourne end and the tribunal reserves its decision.
What happens next
The tribunal must deliver its decision within 90 days of the hearing, so by about mid-February 2027. It can uphold the ACCC's decision or clear the store. Whatever it rules will be read closely by every major supermarket chain, shopping centre owner and developer planning new sites, and by the ACCC as it handles the growing number of deals it must now clear.
Sources
- VNN
VNN never names people who give us information in confidence. How we protect sources and tips.
That is the story in a minute. For the evidence, context and what happens next, switch to the full story.
Weather today
Sunday 22 November
Perth
Mild with rain nearby · 18% rain
20°15°
Sydney heats to 30 and Melbourne 28 while Perth stays mild; rain soaks Paris and New York, and storms build over Sao Paulo.
- Sydney30°19°
- Melbourne28°15°
- Brisbane26°18°
- Adelaide26°17°
- Auckland19°13°
- Singapore30°25°
More cities (13)
- Tokyo13°6°
- Hong Kong21°17°
- Mumbai30°21°
- Dubai31°20°
- Nairobi23°16°
- Lagos30°26°
- Johannesburg28°18°
- London8°5°
- Paris8°7°
- New York14°10°
- Los Angeles18°11°
- Toronto13°5°
- Sao Paulo32°22°
Highs and lows in °C, local time.
Breaking now
Live deskDeveloping stories
Live deskStories we’re following
Live deskMost read this week
For subscribers
Read every subscriber story in full, on any device. Premium reports are sold separately.
Secure payment · Cancel anytime · Subscribers sign in
Markets
Stocks
- Alphabet (GOOGL)Nasdaq265.29 USDdown -2.70%
- Amazon (AMZN)Nasdaq246.82 USDdown -4.10%
- Apple (AAPL)Nasdaq342.56 USDdown -1.90%
- ASX 200ASX8,730down -1.04%
- Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.B)NYSE570.00 USDdown -0.36%
- BHP Group (BHP)ASX51.40 AUDdown -1.80%
Currencies
- AUD/EURForex0.607100 EURdown -0.31%
- AUD/GBPForex0.508500 GBPup +0.02%
- AUD/JPYForex106.1100 JPYdown -0.41%
- AUD/NZDForex1.212700 NZDdown -0.18%
- AUD/USDForex0.666600 USDdown -0.16%
- BTC/USDCrypto58,970.00 USDdown -5.21%
As at 21 Nov 2026, 6:40 am GMT+0800. Entered by VNN. Not financial advice.
For you
Follow the topics you care about and save stories with the bookmark. They gather here, on this device only.
Saved on this device only. Nothing is sent to VNN.
Help keep the lights on.
Independent news costs money to make and nothing to read. Chip in and keep it that way.
ContributeFrom A$5 a month · Cancel anytimeThe daily briefing
Start informed.
The essential headlines, the useful context and what to watch next, in your inbox each morning.







Comments
0 commentsCommunity rules
To read and join the conversation, please agree to our rules.
You have agreed to the community rules.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.