Six weeks, 26 rallies and one missing policy: Australia’s homebirth midwives say the second pair of hands is about to disappear
Thousands of parents, babies and midwives rallied at 26 sites across Australia on Saturday against the end of an insurance exemption, in place since 2009, that lets midwives attend homebirths without private indemnity cover. It ends on 1 January. Health Minister Mark Butler says insurance for every practitioner is overdue, but midwives say the rules leave the second midwife a homebirth legally needs with no cover to buy, and warn that more women will give birth with no midwife at all.
Three things to know
- A planned homebirth legally needs two midwives. Only endorsed midwives, about 5 per cent of Australia's 35,000 registered midwives, can get the insurance that becomes mandatory on 1 January; advocates say the second, supporting midwife is the one left without a product.
- In a survey by the advocacy group Homebirth Australia, 88 per cent of non-endorsed second midwives said they would stop attending homebirths, and 59 per cent of women said they would consider freebirth if they lost their midwife.
- The fight now moves to Canberra, with a rally at Parliament House on Tuesday 24 November, five and a half weeks before the change takes effect.
Thousands of families turned out at 26 sites around the country on Saturday, from Hyde Park in Sydney to the steps of the Northern Territory parliament in Darwin, to fight a change most Australians have never heard of: the end of a 16-year-old insurance exemption that keeps homebirth legal for many of the midwives who attend it.
Homebirth Australia, which organised the rallies, said more than 12,000 people had registered to attend. Hundreds gathered in Sydney, Darwin and Perth, and more than 200 in Hobart, with smaller crowds in Wollongong, Glenelg, Brisbane, Geraldton, Esperance and Wagga Wagga.
What is actually changing?
Since 2009, a temporary exemption has let midwives attend homebirths without private professional indemnity insurance, because no insurer offered a product that covered them. From 1 January 2027, under changes to the Commonwealth’s midwife professional indemnity arrangements, that exemption ends and insurance becomes mandatory.
The catch is in the staffing. A planned homebirth must have two midwives present. The lead midwife must be endorsed, a higher qualification that takes extra study and 5,000 clinical hours, and endorsed midwives can buy the new insurance. The second, supporting midwife does not have to be endorsed, and advocates say there is no product that will insure a registered but non-endorsed midwife for a homebirth. Without one, they say, the second midwife can no longer legally attend.
Only about 5 per cent of Australia’s roughly 35,000 registered midwives are endorsed, according to Nursing and Midwifery Board data.
Why does the government say it is doing this?
Health Minister Mark Butler has called insurance for all health practitioners, midwives included, a “no-brainer”. He has said health ministers across the country agreed 18 months ago to bring midwives into line with other practitioners, and that an insurance product has now been developed and offered to midwives.
Butler has also said he understands the anxiety and wants the balance right between choice and safety.
Who stands to lose the most?
Women outside the cities. In Geraldton, the only privately practising endorsed midwife offering homebirths north of Perth told Saturday’s rally there was no access in the region at all. In Esperance, one endorsed midwife provides the town’s homebirths. In Wagga Wagga, parents said the two local endorsed midwives fill their books fast.
Homebirth Australia’s coordinator, Katelyn Commerford, said some women choose homebirth because their nearest hospital can be three hours’ drive away, and warned of women ending up giving birth on the side of a highway. On a fix, she was blunt: “They could sort this today.”
What is freebirth, and why are midwives worried about it?
Freebirth is giving birth at home on purpose with no midwife or doctor present. Australia does not collect data on it systematically, which is part of the problem: no one can say how often it happens now, let alone how often it would happen after January. Deaths of a number of babies on the NSW north coast are the subject of a coronial inquest.
The Australian College of Midwives says it wants women to be able to reach a midwife who has insurance, and that the answer is to remove the extra hurdles midwives face in getting it. Unions and midwives at the rallies called for a working group to find a permanent, affordable insurance solution, and for the exemption to be extended in the meantime, at least in regional and remote areas.
How many women does this touch?
Homebirth is a small slice of Australian births, and no national homebirth count was offered by either side on Saturday. But 12,000 registrations across 26 sites suggest the number of people paying attention is far larger than the number of births involved.
For anyone pregnant and planning a homebirth after 1 January, the practical step is to ask your midwife now whether both midwives on your birth team will be insured, and to talk with your midwife or doctor about a backup plan.
How we got here
The key moments that brought this story into focus. Open any moment for detail.
2009Exemption begins
Midwives are allowed to attend homebirths without private indemnity insurance because no product covers them.
Mid-2025Ministers agree to change
Health ministers decide to bring midwives into line with other health practitioners on insurance, Health Minister Mark Butler says.
November 2026Butler defends the change
The Health Minister says insurance for all practitioners is a "no-brainer" and a product has been developed.
21 November 2026Rallies at 26 sites
Homebirth Australia says more than 12,000 people registered for rallies from Darwin to Hobart and Perth to Sydney.
What happens next
Homebirth advocates will rally at Parliament House in Canberra on Tuesday 24 November. The exemption ends on 1 January 2027 unless the federal government extends it; no extension, delay or review had been announced by Saturday afternoon. Midwives' groups are asking for a government working group on a permanent insurance solution, and the NSW north coast coronial inquest into the deaths of babies after freebirths is continuing.
Sources
- VNN
VNN never names people who give us information in confidence. How we protect sources and tips.
That is the story in a minute. For the evidence, context and what happens next, switch to the full story.
Weather today
Saturday 21 November
Perth
Cool with a passing shower · 36% rain
19°16°
A cool, showery Saturday for Perth while Adelaide warms to 28; Singapore stays steamy and wet, and London wakes to a 2-degree start.
- Sydney28°18°
- Melbourne24°17°
- Brisbane25°19°
- Adelaide28°15°
- Auckland18°12°
- Singapore29°25°
More cities (13)
- Tokyo13°6°
- Hong Kong21°14°
- Mumbai30°20°
- Dubai30°21°
- Nairobi24°16°
- Lagos32°26°
- Johannesburg26°19°
- London8°2°
- Paris11°7°
- New York15°8°
- Los Angeles18°10°
- Toronto10°5°
- Sao Paulo32°21°
Highs and lows in °C, local time.
Breaking now
Live deskDeveloping stories
Live deskStories we’re following
Live deskMost read this week
For subscribers
Read every subscriber story in full, on any device. Premium reports are sold separately.
Secure payment · Cancel anytime · Subscribers sign in
Markets
Stocks
- Alphabet (GOOGL)Nasdaq265.29 USDdown -2.70%
- Amazon (AMZN)Nasdaq246.82 USDdown -4.10%
- Apple (AAPL)Nasdaq342.56 USDdown -1.90%
- ASX 200ASX8,730down -1.04%
- Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.B)NYSE570.00 USDdown -0.36%
- BHP Group (BHP)ASX51.40 AUDdown -1.80%
Currencies
- AUD/EURForex0.607100 EURdown -0.31%
- AUD/GBPForex0.508500 GBPup +0.02%
- AUD/JPYForex106.1100 JPYdown -0.41%
- AUD/NZDForex1.212700 NZDdown -0.18%
- AUD/USDForex0.666600 USDdown -0.16%
- BTC/USDCrypto58,970.00 USDdown -5.21%
As at 21 Nov 2026, 6:40 am GMT+0800. Entered by VNN. Not financial advice.
For you
Follow the topics you care about and save stories with the bookmark. They gather here, on this device only.
Saved on this device only. Nothing is sent to VNN.
Help keep the lights on.
Independent news costs money to make and nothing to read. Chip in and keep it that way.
ContributeFrom A$5 a month · Cancel anytimeThe daily briefing
Start informed.
The essential headlines, the useful context and what to watch next, in your inbox each morning.







Comments
0 commentsCommunity rules
To read and join the conversation, please agree to our rules.
You have agreed to the community rules.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.