Cut for using words like “diversity”: the Supreme Court won’t rescue Trump’s grant purge at the University of California
The US Supreme Court has refused to hear the Trump administration's appeal over research grants it cancelled for University of California scientists, leaving in place rulings that the cuts likely violated free speech. No justice dissented and the court gave no reasons. It is not a final win for the researchers, but it keeps their grants flowing and their case alive.
Three things to know
- The lower courts found the government likely engaged in viewpoint discrimination, cutting grants flagged in keyword searches for terms such as "diversity" and "climate change".
- The court simply declined the appeal: it did not rule on the merits, and the case goes on in the lower courts.
- The win has a limit: researchers who want lost money paid back must still sue in a separate court, the Court of Federal Claims.
The US Supreme Court on Monday, 16 November, US time, turned away the Trump administration’s appeal in a fight over cancelled research grants to University of California researchers, the latest legal setback for the White House’s campaign against diversity, equity and inclusion programs.
The case, Trump v. Thakur, was brought by UC researchers whose grants from the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities were terminated last year as the administration moved against hundreds of millions of dollars in funding to the university system.
As is usual when it declines a case, the court gave no explanation. No justice publicly dissented.
What did the lower courts decide?
US District Judge Rita Lin in San Francisco blocked the terminations of grants cut over their links to DEI, finding the researchers were likely to succeed in their claim that the cuts amounted to unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination under the First Amendment.
The researchers argued that grants were singled out through keyword searches for disfavoured words such as “diversity” and “climate change”. The 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that part of Lin’s ruling, and the administration took it to the Supreme Court.
By refusing the appeal, the justices left those rulings standing. Some of the cancelled funding had already resumed under the lower court orders.
Is this a final victory for the researchers?
No. Declining an appeal is not a ruling on who is right, and the case now returns to the district court.
There is also a significant catch. In a part of the case that was not before the Supreme Court, the 9th Circuit ruled that researchers who want to recover money already lost must file a separate lawsuit in the Court of Federal Claims, a specialised court for money claims against the US government.
That split follows the Supreme Court’s own lead. In August 2025, in a case over cancelled National Institutes of Health grants, a divided court let those cuts proceed and said disputes over grant money belonged in the Court of Federal Claims, while leaving room to challenge the policies behind the cuts in ordinary federal courts. Monday’s refusal suggests the justices are content, for now, with lower courts hearing free speech challenges like this one.
Why does it matter beyond California?
The UC system is one of the largest research enterprises in the world, and its scientists work with partners across the globe, including in Australia. The administration’s grant cancellations have reached universities across the United States; how the courts treat claims that grants were cut for the words researchers used will shape how much protection academics have when governments disagree with what they study.
Who pays for this?
For now, the federal government keeps paying the grants covered by the court orders. Whether researchers recover money from the period their funding was cut off will be fought separately, in the Court of Federal Claims.
How we got here
The key moments that brought this story into focus. Open any moment for detail.
2025Grants cancelled
Federal agencies terminate grants to UC researchers, including from the NSF and NEH, as part of the push against DEI programs.
August 2025NIH grants ruling
A divided Supreme Court lets NIH grant cuts proceed and sends money claims to the Court of Federal Claims.
2025Judge Rita Lin rules
A federal judge in San Francisco blocks the DEI-related terminations as likely viewpoint discrimination.
20269th Circuit
The appeals court upholds that part of the ruling but sends claims for lost money to the Court of Federal Claims.
16 November 2026Supreme Court declines
The justices refuse the administration's appeal, without explanation or dissent.
What happens next
The case returns to Judge Lin's court for further proceedings on the researchers' First Amendment claims. Researchers seeking repayment of lost funding must bring separate claims in the Court of Federal Claims. VNN will report the next rulings in the case.
Sources
- VNN
VNN never names people who give us information in confidence. How we protect sources and tips.
That is the story in a minute. For the evidence, context and what happens next, switch to the full story.
Weather today
Monday 16 November
Perth
Warm under grey skies · 10% rain
27°16°
A warm, grey Monday for Perth; heavy showers soak Brisbane and Singapore, Paris stays wet and London wakes cold but bright.
- Sydney18°15°
- Melbourne14°9°
- Brisbane28°20°
- Adelaide19°10°
- Auckland21°15°
- Singapore28°25°
More cities (13)
- Tokyo18°13°
- Hong Kong26°20°
- Mumbai32°23°
- Dubai30°20°
- Nairobi24°16°
- Lagos31°26°
- Johannesburg27°15°
- London7°4°
- Paris11°10°
- New York10°4°
- Los Angeles20°16°
- Toronto9°4°
- Sao Paulo25°19°
Highs and lows in °C, local time.
Breaking now
Live deskDeveloping stories
Live deskMost read this week
For subscribers
Read every subscriber story in full, on any device. Premium reports are sold separately.
Secure payment · Cancel anytime · Subscribers sign in
Markets
Stocks
- Alphabet (GOOGL)Nasdaq295.77 USDdown -0.98%
- Amazon (AMZN)Nasdaq266.66 USDdown -0.29%
- Apple (AAPL)Nasdaq356.27 USDup +0.39%
- ASX 200ASX9,082.20down -0.71%
- Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.B)NYSE592.94 USDup +0.53%
- BHP Group (BHP)ASX58.86 AUDdown -1.26%
Currencies
- AUD/EURForex0.613500 EURdown -0.29%
- AUD/GBPForex0.511800 GBPdown -0.47%
- AUD/JPYForex107.8800 JPYdown -0.85%
- AUD/NZDForex1.224200 NZDdown -0.25%
- AUD/USDForex0.675900 USDdown -0.66%
- BTC/USDCrypto68,241.00 USDdown -4.59%
As at 14 Nov 2026, 5:52 am GMT+0800. Entered by VNN. Not financial advice.
For you
Follow the topics you care about and save stories with the bookmark. They gather here, on this device only.
Saved on this device only. Nothing is sent to VNN.
Help keep the lights on.
Independent news costs money to make and nothing to read. Chip in and keep it that way.
ContributeFrom A$5 a month · Cancel anytimeThe daily briefing
Start informed.
The essential headlines, the useful context and what to watch next, in your inbox each morning.







Comments
0 commentsCommunity rules
To read and join the conversation, please agree to our rules.
You have agreed to the community rules.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.