Trump said “do it”, then the margin did it in: the Justice Department drops its fight to stall Mary Peltola’s Alaska win
The US Justice Department has abandoned its lawsuit seeking to hold up certification of Democrat Mary Peltola's Alaska Senate victory, telling a federal appeals court the case has become moot. Ms Peltola won by more than four percentage points, a margin wide enough that the second "Dan Sullivan" on the ballot could not have changed the result. A separate criminal investigation into how that second candidate came to run is continuing.
Three things to know
- The suit was built for a close race: it asked that certification be held if Senator Dan Sullivan lost by fewer votes than a second candidate named Dan J. Sullivan received. Ms Peltola's margin was larger than that.
- The Justice Department still says its case had merit, but concedes it can no longer work out how votes for Dan J. Sullivan were meant to be cast.
- The fight is not over: the federal criminal probe, a state inquiry ordered by Governor Mike Dunleavy and Alaska's challenge deadlines all remain.
President Donald Trump ordered the lawsuit before election day and later said so: “I’m the one that said ‘do it.'” On Thursday evening US time, two days after Mary Peltola was projected the winner, his Justice Department asked to walk away from it.
In a filing to the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals, Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward, the department’s third-ranking official, asked the court to vacate a lower court’s dismissal of the case because it “has become moot”.
Ms Peltola, a former congresswoman, beat Republican Senator Dan Sullivan by more than four percentage points and won an outright majority of first-choice votes in Alaska’s ranked-choice system. She is set to become the first Alaska Native to serve in the US Senate when the new Congress meets on 3 January, and the seat is the ninth Democratic pickup of the midterms.
What was the “two Sullivans” case?
Alaska’s ballot carried two Dan Sullivans: the Republican senator, and Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired schoolteacher from Petersburg. Republicans called his run a sham designed to split the senator’s vote. Mr Sullivan Jr. has long said the decision to run was his own, and Ms Peltola has denied any role.
The department sued Alaska’s election officials on 22 October, asking that the Senate result not be certified if the senator lost by fewer votes than his namesake received, until investigators could establish whether those voters had meant to choose the senator. It also sought to have ballots cast for Dan J. Sullivan set aside.
US District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the case on 1 November, two days before the election, finding there was no workable plan to investigate the vote. The department appealed the same day.
Is anyone in legal trouble?
No one has been charged. The Justice Department opened a criminal investigation in October into whether Democrats recruited the second candidate to confuse voters. Target letters went out on election day, including to Marc Elias, whose law firm represents Ms Peltola’s campaign. Mr Elias said the department was targeting him and his firm on election day. It is unclear whether recruiting a candidate with the same name breaks any criminal law.
Attorney General Todd Blanche has said the investigation continues, and the Alaska Bureau of Investigation says the state inquiry ordered by Governor Dunleavy is also ongoing. Mr Trump has called for Ms Peltola to be prosecuted.
What do the two candidates say?
Ms Peltola said that for Alaskans, “there is only one direction: forward”. Senator Sullivan has not conceded. His campaign said on Monday it would let the process run until every legal vote was counted and certified.
Why does it matter beyond Alaska?
It is at least the second time since election day that the Justice Department has dropped a high-profile election case, after it abandoned a challenge involving about 20,000 California ballots. Both cases tested how far the federal government can go in contesting elections that the states run.
How we got here
The key moments that brought this story into focus. Open any moment for detail.
12 January 2026Peltola enters
Mary Peltola announces her run against Senator Dan Sullivan.
October 2026Criminal probe
The Justice Department opens an investigation into the recruitment of a second "Dan Sullivan".
22 October 2026Lawsuit filed
The department sues Alaska election officials to hold up certification in a close result.
1 November 2026Case dismissed
Judge Sharon Gleason throws out the suit; the department appeals.
3 November 2026Election day
Target letters go out in the criminal probe, including to Marc Elias.
17 November 2026Peltola projected
Ms Peltola is projected the winner by more than four points.
19 November 2026Suit dropped
The department tells the 9th Circuit the case is moot.
What happens next
Alaska's Division of Elections has set 25 November as its target date to certify the result. The last day to seek a recount is 30 November, and the last day to challenge the outcome in the state superior court is 5 December. The 9th Circuit has still to rule on the department's motion. The new Congress, with Ms Peltola sworn in, convenes on 3 January 2027.
Sources
- VNN
VNN never names people who give us information in confidence. How we protect sources and tips.
That is the story in a minute. For the evidence, context and what happens next, switch to the full story.
Weather today
Sunday 22 November
Perth
Mild with rain nearby · 18% rain
20°15°
Sydney heats to 30 and Melbourne 28 while Perth stays mild; rain soaks Paris and New York, and storms build over Sao Paulo.
- Sydney30°19°
- Melbourne28°15°
- Brisbane26°18°
- Adelaide26°17°
- Auckland19°13°
- Singapore30°25°
More cities (13)
- Tokyo13°6°
- Hong Kong21°17°
- Mumbai30°21°
- Dubai31°20°
- Nairobi23°16°
- Lagos30°26°
- Johannesburg28°18°
- London8°5°
- Paris8°7°
- New York14°10°
- Los Angeles18°11°
- Toronto13°5°
- Sao Paulo32°22°
Highs and lows in °C, local time.
Breaking now
Live deskDeveloping stories
Live deskStories we’re following
Live deskMost read this week
For subscribers
Read every subscriber story in full, on any device. Premium reports are sold separately.
Secure payment · Cancel anytime · Subscribers sign in
Markets
Stocks
- Alphabet (GOOGL)Nasdaq265.29 USDdown -2.70%
- Amazon (AMZN)Nasdaq246.82 USDdown -4.10%
- Apple (AAPL)Nasdaq342.56 USDdown -1.90%
- ASX 200ASX8,730down -1.04%
- Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.B)NYSE570.00 USDdown -0.36%
- BHP Group (BHP)ASX51.40 AUDdown -1.80%
Currencies
- AUD/EURForex0.607100 EURdown -0.31%
- AUD/GBPForex0.508500 GBPup +0.02%
- AUD/JPYForex106.1100 JPYdown -0.41%
- AUD/NZDForex1.212700 NZDdown -0.18%
- AUD/USDForex0.666600 USDdown -0.16%
- BTC/USDCrypto58,970.00 USDdown -5.21%
As at 21 Nov 2026, 6:40 am GMT+0800. Entered by VNN. Not financial advice.
For you
Follow the topics you care about and save stories with the bookmark. They gather here, on this device only.
Saved on this device only. Nothing is sent to VNN.
Help keep the lights on.
Independent news costs money to make and nothing to read. Chip in and keep it that way.
ContributeFrom A$5 a month · Cancel anytimeThe daily briefing
Start informed.
The essential headlines, the useful context and what to watch next, in your inbox each morning.







Comments
0 commentsCommunity rules
To read and join the conversation, please agree to our rules.
You have agreed to the community rules.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.