“Yes, they are wrong”: Marles takes on Washington’s own budget office over the subs Australia is paying A$368 billion for
Defence Minister Richard Marles says the US Congressional Budget Office is wrong to find that selling Virginia-class submarines to Australia would leave the US Navy with fewer attack submarines for years. The non-partisan office, which advises the US Congress, released the report on Friday. Mr Marles says American shipyards are speeding up and the deal "is very much happening".
Three things to know
- The Congressional Budget Office says the US submarine industry is already struggling to meet the US Navy's own demand, and that selling boats to Australia would cut the number of US attack submarines available for many years.
- Mr Marles says US production is "absolutely increasing", but agrees the build rate is critical to Australia getting its submarines, still due from the early 2030s.
- The CBO report is the latest of several from Washington questioning AUKUS; Mr Marles says he expects many more over the next decade.
Richard Marles has bluntly rejected a finding by the US Congressional Budget Office that the AUKUS submarine deal would weaken America’s own undersea fleet.
The CBO, the independent office that costs policy for the US Congress, released a report on Friday saying the US submarine industrial base is “currently struggling to meet the Navy’s demand for submarines”. It said the sale of nuclear-powered attack submarines to Australia would reduce the number available to the US Navy for many years, with the effect lasting through to 2060.
Asked in a television interview on Sunday whether the CBO was wrong, Mr Marles said: “Yes, they are wrong.” He said “the production rate in the United States is absolutely increasing”.
Why does a US budget report matter to Australia?
Under AUKUS, the United States is due to sell Australia several Virginia-class submarines from the early 2030s, before Australia and Britain build a new AUKUS-class boat. Australia has committed up to A$368 billion over three decades to the program.
The sale depends on US shipyards building submarines faster than they are now. US law requires the American president to certify that handing boats to Australia will not weaken the US Navy’s own capability, so a finding from Congress’s own budget office that the US fleet would shrink lands directly on the question the sale hinges on.
What did Marles concede?
Mr Marles said he was not worried by the report and expected to see many like it over the next decade. “The reason it doesn’t worry me is because AUKUS is very much happening,” he said.
He agreed the American shipbuilding rate was “definitely a critical part” of Australia receiving its submarines, and said sustainment and maintenance mattered as well. He said Australia was still aiming to receive its first Virginia-class submarine in the early 2030s. US-commanded Virginia-class submarines are due to begin rotating through Australia from next year.
The CBO did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
What else is Canberra pushing back on?
Mr Marles also addressed US President Donald Trump’s statement that he would not allow American AI companies to build data centres in foreign countries, and his warning of “tremendous taxes” for those that do.
Australia has attracted at least $35 billion in data centre investment, a record, as of September. Mr Marles said it was in the United States’ interest for data centres to be built in Australia, and that concentrating infrastructure in the US created a vulnerability. “We need to be doing it on our terms,” he said.
Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke said there was a “national security” interest in Australia hosting AI data centres, but warned such facilities could become a magnet for foreign interference, so their ownership structures needed care. ASIO director-general Mike Burgess has warned that foreign actors building data centres may try to gain covert access to sensitive information or critical infrastructure. Mr Marles said that was “a concern”.
Why does this matter for taxpayers?
AUKUS is the most expensive defence project in Australia’s history. Spread across Australia’s population, the A$368 billion commitment is roughly A$13,000 for every person in the country. The money is committed on the assumption that American yards will deliver boats on time without leaving the US short, and that assumption is exactly what the CBO is questioning.
China has called the pact dangerous and warned it could spark an arms race in the region.
How we got here
The key moments that brought this story into focus. Open any moment for detail.
September 2021AUKUS announced
Australia, Britain and the United States form the pact, with nuclear-powered submarines at its centre.
October 2026On track, says Marles
Mr Marles says Australia remains on track for its first US submarines in the early 2030s.
20 November 2026CBO report
The US Congressional Budget Office says selling Virginia-class submarines to Australia would reduce the US attack submarine fleet for many years.
22 November 2026"They are wrong"
Mr Marles rejects the finding and says US production is increasing.
What happens next
US-commanded Virginia-class submarines are due to start rotating through Australia from 2027. The first sale of a Virginia-class boat to Australia is planned for the early 2030s, subject to the US president's certification. Watch for any response from the CBO and from members of the US Congress, who will weigh the report in future defence budgets.
Sources
- VNN
VNN never names people who give us information in confidence. How we protect sources and tips.
That is the story in a minute. For the evidence, context and what happens next, switch to the full story.
Weather today
Sunday 22 November
Perth
Mild with rain nearby · 18% rain
20°15°
Sydney heats to 30 and Melbourne 28 while Perth stays mild; rain soaks Paris and New York, and storms build over Sao Paulo.
- Sydney30°19°
- Melbourne28°15°
- Brisbane26°18°
- Adelaide26°17°
- Auckland19°13°
- Singapore30°25°
More cities (13)
- Tokyo13°6°
- Hong Kong21°17°
- Mumbai30°21°
- Dubai31°20°
- Nairobi23°16°
- Lagos30°26°
- Johannesburg28°18°
- London8°5°
- Paris8°7°
- New York14°10°
- Los Angeles18°11°
- Toronto13°5°
- Sao Paulo32°22°
Highs and lows in °C, local time.
Breaking now
Live deskDeveloping stories
Live deskStories we’re following
Live deskMost read this week
For subscribers
Read every subscriber story in full, on any device. Premium reports are sold separately.
Secure payment · Cancel anytime · Subscribers sign in
Markets
Stocks
- Alphabet (GOOGL)Nasdaq265.29 USDdown -2.70%
- Amazon (AMZN)Nasdaq246.82 USDdown -4.10%
- Apple (AAPL)Nasdaq342.56 USDdown -1.90%
- ASX 200ASX8,730down -1.04%
- Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.B)NYSE570.00 USDdown -0.36%
- BHP Group (BHP)ASX51.40 AUDdown -1.80%
Currencies
- AUD/EURForex0.607100 EURdown -0.31%
- AUD/GBPForex0.508500 GBPup +0.02%
- AUD/JPYForex106.1100 JPYdown -0.41%
- AUD/NZDForex1.212700 NZDdown -0.18%
- AUD/USDForex0.666600 USDdown -0.16%
- BTC/USDCrypto58,970.00 USDdown -5.21%
As at 21 Nov 2026, 6:40 am GMT+0800. Entered by VNN. Not financial advice.
For you
Follow the topics you care about and save stories with the bookmark. They gather here, on this device only.
Saved on this device only. Nothing is sent to VNN.
Help keep the lights on.
Independent news costs money to make and nothing to read. Chip in and keep it that way.
ContributeFrom A$5 a month · Cancel anytimeThe daily briefing
Start informed.
The essential headlines, the useful context and what to watch next, in your inbox each morning.







Comments
0 commentsCommunity rules
To read and join the conversation, please agree to our rules.
You have agreed to the community rules.
No comments yet. Start the conversation.